top of page
Search

Open Riser vs Closed Riser Stairs

  • Writer: Jose Vivanco
    Jose Vivanco
  • 5 hours ago
  • 6 min read

Choosing between open riser and closed riser stairs affects more than aesthetics. The decision impacts noise levels, cleaning routines, safety with children and pets, and long-term maintenance costs in your Fairfax, Springfield, or Annandale home.


Open riser staircases create airy, modern spaces by eliminating vertical boards between treads. Closed riser designs enclose each step completely, offering traditional appeal and practical advantages. Both styles meet Virginia building codes when properly constructed, but each suits different households and design goals.


Open Riser vs Closed Riser Stairs - Vivanco's Trim

This guide breaks down the real-world differences to help you choose the right staircase for your home and lifestyle.



Table of Contents




Key Takeaways


  • Open risers create modern, spacious aesthetics but require careful safety planning

  • Closed risers offer superior sound dampening and safety for households with small children

  • Virginia code allows open risers when gaps prevent 4-inch sphere passage

  • Maintenance difficulty increases with open designs due to visible dust accumulation


Need professional guidance on staircase design? Contact Vivanco's Trim for custom stair solutions in Northern Virginia.



What Are Open Riser Stairs?


Open riser staircases eliminate the vertical board (riser) between each tread, leaving the space open. You can see through the staircase from one side to the other. This design originated in mid-century modern architecture and has surged in popularity within contemporary and minimalist homes.


The open construction requires stronger structural support since treads lack backing reinforcement. Each tread typically connects directly to stringers with metal brackets, bolts, or specialized hardware. Materials range from thick hardwood treads to steel, glass, or floating designs that appear to defy gravity.


Virginia building code permits open riser construction on stairs more than 30 inches above grade only when openings prevent a 4-inch diameter sphere from passing through. This typically requires adding horizontal rails, cables, or glass panels between treads.



What Are Closed Riser Stairs?


Closed riser stairs feature vertical boards connecting each tread, completely enclosing the space between steps. This traditional design has dominated residential construction for decades due to proven safety, durability, and versatility.


The riser board provides structural support, allowing the staircase to bear weight more efficiently across its entire surface. Construction methods vary from simple nailed risers to sophisticated interlocking joints that eliminate squeaks and movement.


Closed risers work with any architectural style, from colonial to craftsman to transitional designs. The enclosed construction creates usable storage space beneath stairs, a practical advantage in homes where square footage matters.


Looking for traditional staircase inspiration? Explore our guide to traditional stair handrails and classic profiles.



Open vs Closed Riser: Visual Impact

Design Aspect

Open Riser

Closed Riser

Spatial perception

Expands visual space, increases light flow

Defines separate zones, anchors rooms

Style compatibility

Modern, contemporary, industrial, Scandinavian

Traditional, transitional, colonial, craftsman

Light transmission

Allows natural light between floors

Blocks light transfer completely

Visual weight

Appears lighter, less imposing

Provides substantial architectural presence

Open riser staircases excel in compact spaces where visual expansion matters. The see-through design prevents stairs from dominating small entryways or open-concept living areas. Light flows freely between floors, reducing the need for additional fixtures in adjacent spaces.


Closed riser stairs provide architectural definition. They create clear boundaries between floors and serve as focal points in entryways. The solid construction offers canvas space for painted finishes, stain variations, or decorative trim details that enhance traditional interiors.


Material selection amplifies these differences. Glass or acrylic treads on open risers maximize transparency, while thick hardwood treads on closed risers add warmth and traditional appeal.



Safety Considerations for Kids and Pets


Open riser stairs present legitimate safety concerns for households with young children or small pets. Toddlers learning to climb stairs can slip feet or hands through openings, leading to falls or trapped limbs. Small dogs and cats may attempt to jump through gaps, risking injury.


Virginia code addresses this by requiring that openings not allow 4-inch sphere passage when stairs exceed 30 inches in height. Compliance typically requires:


  • Horizontal cables spaced at maximum 4-inch intervals

  • Glass or acrylic panels filling the void between treads

  • Mesh screening that maintains modern aesthetics while closing gaps


The gap between tread and bottom rail receives slightly more tolerance at 6 inches, but most families with young children prefer tighter spacing or full enclosure.


Closed riser stairs eliminate these concerns entirely. Children cannot see through to the other side, reducing temptation to climb recklessly or poke objects through openings. Pets navigate closed stairs more confidently since they perceive solid surfaces beneath each step.


Accidents on open riser stairs also involve objects. Dropped items fall straight through to lower floors, creating hazards for anyone below. Toys, phones, and small household items require retrieval from basement levels or beneath stairwells.


Ready to design stairs that balance style with family safety? See our modern stair railing ideas for code-compliant solutions.



Noise and Sound Transfer


Sound travels differently through open versus closed riser construction, affecting whole-home acoustics.


Open Riser Noise Profile: Each footstep creates direct sound that travels unobstructed between floors. Hard tread materials like steel, concrete, or hardwood amplify impact noise. Sound waves move through open spaces without absorption, making every step audible throughout adjacent rooms. Homes with open risers near bedrooms or home offices often require additional soundproofing measures.


Closed Riser Noise Profile: The enclosed design dampens sound naturally. Riser boards absorb and deflect impact vibrations, reducing transmission to surrounding spaces. Properly constructed closed stairs with quality underlayment produce minimal noise even during heavy use. Carpet runners further reduce sound, an option that works better with closed riser designs.


Families with early risers, shift workers, or noise-sensitive schedules typically prefer closed risers. The acoustic benefits maintain household peace without additional sound engineering investments.


Cleaning and Maintenance


Maintenance requirements differ substantially between designs.


Open Riser Maintenance: Dust accumulates visibly on exposed tread undersides, requiring regular cleaning from multiple angles. Cobwebs form in corners and along stringers, visible from below. Spills drip through to lower levels, creating cleanup challenges on multiple surfaces. Each tread needs individual attention during deep cleaning, increasing time investment.


The open design does offer advantages: easy access for repair work, simple hardware inspection, and no hidden moisture accumulation that rots enclosed wood.


Closed Riser Maintenance: Standard vacuuming and mopping cover most cleaning needs. Enclosed construction hides dust accumulation beneath treads and within stringer cavities. Carpet runners simplify maintenance further while protecting tread surfaces from wear.


The disadvantage appears during repair scenarios. Accessing structural components requires removing trim, risers, or treads to diagnose squeaks, settling, or damage. Hidden moisture problems can develop undetected.


Maintenance Factor

Open Riser

Closed Riser

Routine cleaning time

40-60 minutes weekly

15-25 minutes weekly

Visible dust buildup

High, requires frequent attention

Low, enclosed design hides accumulation

Repair accessibility

Excellent, all components visible

Moderate, may require disassembly



Best Fit Recommendations


Choose Open Riser Stairs If:


  • Your home features modern, contemporary, or industrial design

  • You prioritize natural light flow between floors

  • The staircase sits in a compact space needing visual expansion

  • Household members are adults or older children without mobility concerns

  • Budget allows for premium construction and maintenance

  • You appreciate architectural statements over traditional comfort


Choose Closed Riser Stairs If:


  • Children under age 8 or small pets live in the home

  • Noise control between floors matters for your schedule

  • You prefer traditional, transitional, or classic architectural styles

  • Maintenance simplicity ranks high in priorities

  • Budget constraints require cost-effective solutions

  • Under-stair storage would benefit your space planning


Hybrid Solutions: Some homeowners split the difference with partial open risers on upper sections where safety matters less, combined with closed risers near ground floors. Others add removable panels that close gaps during early childhood years, then convert to open design later.


Understanding the parts of a staircase helps you make informed design choices for any configuration.



Get Expert Staircase Design and Installation


The right staircase balances aesthetics, safety, budget, and household needs. Vivanco's Trim designs and builds custom staircases throughout Fairfax, Springfield, and Annandale, with expertise in both open and closed riser construction.


Our team handles permitting, code compliance, and installation from concept to completion. Whether you envision modern floating treads or classic hardwood stairs, we deliver craftsmanship that stands the test of time.


Schedule your free consultation to discuss your staircase project today.



FAQs


Are open riser stairs safe for toddlers? Open riser stairs pose risks for children under age 5 who might slip through gaps or get limbs stuck. Virginia code requires 4-inch maximum openings when stairs exceed 30 inches in height. Families with toddlers should add cable rails, glass panels, or choose closed riser designs.


How much more do open riser stairs cost? Open riser staircases typically cost 15-30% more than closed riser designs due to thicker treads, specialized hardware, and code-required safety infill. A standard flight ranges from $8,000-$15,000 for open risers versus $5,500-$10,000 for closed risers.


Do open riser stairs make more noise? Yes. Open riser designs allow sound to travel directly between floors without absorption. Each footstep creates audible impact noise throughout adjacent spaces. Closed risers dampen sound naturally through enclosed construction.


Can you add risers to existing open stairs? Adding risers to existing open stairs is possible but requires structural assessment. The conversion affects load distribution and may need reinforcement. Professional installation ensures code compliance and structural integrity.


Which staircase design works better for small spaces? Open riser stairs excel in compact spaces by allowing light flow and creating visual expansion. The see-through design prevents stairs from dominating small entryways or appearing heavy in open-concept layouts.



References:




 
 
 
bottom of page